“雪佛龙尊让原则”(Chevron Deference Doctrine,以下简称“Chevron原则”)是以1984年的“雪佛龙诉自然资源保护委员会”(Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc.)[1]一案命名。在此案中,美国最高法院以6比0一致票数作出了有利于自然资源保护委员会的判决。最高法院判决中表示[2]: 当国会...
通过简明扼要地介绍“Chevron原则”被“Loper Bright案”推翻后可能造成的美国立法、司法和行政部门之间的新权力平衡趋势,探讨在应对美国出口管制和制裁挑战方面的新路径。 作者丨王峰 王安艺 刘丰仪 范安琪 一、“Chevron原则”是什么? “...
一、“Chevron原则”是什么? “雪佛龙尊让原则”(Chevron Deference Doctrine,以下简称“Chevron原则”)是以1984年的“雪佛龙诉自然资源保护委员会”(Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc.)[1]一案命名。在此案中,美国最高法院以6比0一致票数作出了有利于自然资源保护委员会的判决。最高...
Holland & Knight announced the formation of its Chevron Deference Working Team in advance of the U.S. Supreme Court's June 28, 2024, Loper decision, which overturned the Chevron deference doctrine and will lead to a period of regulatory changes and potential legal challenges for some ...
The court significantly limited Chevron in 2022 when it adopted the so-called“major questions doctrine.”That doctrine reverses the rule of deference in cases when an agency takes a highly consequential action reflecting a previously unheralded expansion in the scope of its authority. In those v...
Healthcare attorney Shannon Hartsfield was quoted in a Law360 article discussing how the U.S. Supreme Court's decision on the Chevron deference doctrine could affect various aspects of healthcare law. The article highlighted several areas that could be vulnerable to legal challenges if C...
Since the Chevron decision in 1984, courts have extended to administrative agen-cies a high level of deference when those agencies reasonably interpret ambiguous statutes, reasoning that agencies have more technical expertise and public accounta-bility than courts. However, when the agency's ...
JusticeElena Kagan,writing in dissent for the three-justice minority, strongly disagrees with Roberts’s interpretations and conclusions. For one thing, she argues, “This court has long understood Chevron deference to reflect what Congress would want, and so to be rooted in a presumption of legi...
The Chevron doctrine The 1984 “Chevron doctrine” — also known as “Chevron deference” — instructed courts, when evaluating federal agency interpretations of statutes, to first determine whether Congress explicitly addressed the specific issue in question. If congressional intent was clear, n...
The Supreme Court has overturned the Chevron deference in a 6-3 vote in a major push toward eliminating government overreach. The 1984 Chevron U.S.A. v.